Categories
Audio Review - South Caucasus News

IMF Calls for Bolstering Judicial System, Anti-corruption Authority in Staff Concluding Statement


On March 18, the International Monetary Fund (IMF) released the preliminary findings of the IMF staff during its official visit to Georgia on March 6-18. The concluding statement, to the publication of which the authorities have consented, provides an overview of the economic situation in Georgia and suggests that the country should strengthen its resilience to adverse shocks by maintaining prudent macroeconomic policies, and raise its growth potential by addressing long-standing structural challenges.

A Concluding Statement describes the preliminary findings of IMF staff at the end of an official staff visit (or ‘mission’), in most cases to a member country. Missions are undertaken as part of regular (usually annual) consultations under Article IV of the IMF’s Articles of Agreement, in the context of a request to use IMF resources (borrow from the IMF), as part of discussions of staff monitored programs, or as part of other staff monitoring of economic developments.

Recent developments, outlook, and risks

The IMF notes that despite the economic crises following Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, Georgia’s financial inflows remain above pre-war levels, supporting “continued strong economic performance.” GDP stood at 7.5% in 2023 and is expected by IMF staff to decline to 5.7% in 2024, “with consumption playing a larger role supported by strong real wage growth and employment.”

Regarding inflation, the IMF states that the 0.4% reached in 2023 is expected to rise to 4% by the end of this year “as the impact of last year’s favorable external factors dissipates and the restrictive monetary policy stance is unwound”. The current account deficit is also expected to widen, from a historically low 4.5% of GDP in 2023 (mainly due to lower remittances from Russia) to 6% by the end of 2024.

The IMF notes that the 2024 budget targets a deficit of 2.5%, supported by higher revenues from corporate income tax (CIT) and new gambling taxes. This will finance higher spending on wages, social benefits and capital investment, while keeping public debt below 40% of GDP.

However, the expected downside risks include uncertainty about war-related migrants and financial inflows, potential reversals in migration and tourism, and geopolitical instability. A loss of momentum or backsliding in the reform agenda is also named as a downside risk. Upside risks include increased transit trade and investments, with shifting geo-economic patterns creating new trade opportunities, and EU candidate status sending a positive signal to investors, says the concluding statement.

Policy priorities

“Macroeconomic and financial policies should be geared towards ensuring strong, sustained, and inclusive growth, continued resilience in the face of an uncertain external environment, and the goal of making decisive progress towards EU accession,” suggests the statement.

Regarding fiscal policy, the IMF staff recommends “modest fiscal adjustments” supported by a focus on revenue enhancement, streamlined tax policies, and efficient spending. In addition, the implementation of reforms in state-owned enterprises (SOEs) and the development of renewable energy is crucial to boost productivity, limit fiscal risks, and align with EU principles.

The IMF emphasizes that the SOE law should ensure that the Ministry of Finance is adequately empowered to play a strong oversight role to monitor and mitigate fiscal risks, as well as limit the state’s interests in line with the Stand-By Arrangement signed in 2022. “Efforts to concretely reduce the state’s footprint in the economy need to be intensified.” The statement also says the authorities should proceed with the opening of the electricity market, which has been delayed again.

Regarding monetary and exchange rate policies, the IMF notes that continued exchange rate flexibility and reserve accumulation are necessary to guard against adverse external shocks, and that strengthening the governance and independence of the NBG is essential for the credibility of monetary policy. “In this regard, the NBG law should be amended to i) ensure a non-executive majority on the NBG’s oversight board, ii) clarify and strengthen the succession framework and board member qualification criteria, and iii) move from a presidential to collegial decision-making model.”

Financial sector resilience and structural reforms

The concluding statement highlights that the Georgian banking system is “well capitalized, profitable, and liquid but remains highly concentrated and dollarized.” It also underlines that “continued vigilance is needed against financial sector risks, including from capital inflows, virtual assets, and sanctions.”

The IMF notes that to foster robust growth, Georgia must improve education, productivity, infrastructure, and governance. This includes enhancing teaching quality, agricultural productivity, and land management, while also investing in transport, logistics, and energy.

“While Georgia ranks high in the region and among EU candidates regarding the rule of law and absence of corruption, recent years have seen some slippages in governance indicators. To ensure that governance standards strengthen and support improved competitiveness, Georgia needs to bolster its judicial system and strengthen the anti-corruption authority,” – notes the statement.

Also Read:


Categories
Audio Review - South Caucasus News

Government Increases Funding For Patriarchate


On March 19, the Prime Minister of Georgia Irakli Kobakhidze said that last year the government earmarked GEL 30 million [est. USD 11,194,000] in the 2024 state budget to support the educational projects of the Patriarchate of Georgia, which was since increased by GEL 5 million [about USD 1,866,000]. The decree, setting the amount at GEL 35 million was issued by the government on March 15.

In addition to these funds, the Patriarchate of Georgia also receives the annual funding in the amount of GEL 25 million [est. USD 9,328,000], bringing the total amount of state funding to GEL 60 million [est. USD 22,388,000] in 2024.

Prime Minister Irakli Kobakhidze denied that the increase has anything to do with the upcoming elections: “This funding was included in this year’s budget last year, so it has nothing to do with the elections, it is not a recent decision, a decision made right before the elections. It is important for us that the Patriarchate can implement its own projects, especially in the field of education.”

Meanwhile, on March 12, the Georgian government issued a decree handing over plots of land to the Orthodox Church in the Ozurgeti and Chokhatauri municipalities in western Georgia for a symbolic price of GEL 1 [USD 0.37].


Categories
South Caucasus News

IMF Resident Representative: Two Scenarios for Stand-by Arrangement Revival


On March 19, the International Monetary Fund’s (IMF) Resident Representative for Georgia, Andrew Jewell, said that the delayed Stand-by Arrangement /SBA could be canceled due to lack of time for renegotiation. According to Jewell, the arrangement could be continued if the government showed a willingness to live up to past commitments, including the consideration of IMF-suggested reforms in the law on state-owned enterprises (SOEs).

The IMF-supported program originally included a three-year stand-by arrangement with a loan of $289 million. After the completion of the first tranche of $40 million, Georgia was due to receive the second tranche this summer, but the IMF postponed the submission and Board approval of the second review of Georgia’s Stand-by Arrangement /SBA, stating that the delay in Board approval was “partly due to disagreement over a change in the NBG’s management structure”.

In a commentary for Business Media, Andrew Jewell noted that the IMF-supported program is for three years and expires in June 2025. Because 2024 is a parliamentary election year, Jewell suggested that Georgia may not be able to implement financial reforms, so instead of renegotiating the delayed Stand-by Arrangement /SBA, it may be more beneficial for Georgia to wait until after the elections and then begin negotiations for a new program in 2025.

Therefore, Jewell suggested two scenarios: if the government wants to revive the program, the IMF is ready to present the measures that need to be implemented; on the other hand, if it believes that now is not the right time and is unwilling to live up to past commitments, then starting talks on a new program next year will be more effective.

Andrew Jewell also mentioned the draft law on state-owned enterprises (SOE), which is not fully in line the reform strategy developed by the IMF and the World Bank in 2022 and agreed by the Georgian government. He noted that the government has reservations about taking on the commitments it made by signing the strategy document two years ago and that negotiations are underway to find other ways to address the problems in the SOE legislation.

According to Jewell, it is important to make the sector more efficient, to ensure the necessary financial oversight powers of the Ministry of Finance over state-owned enterprises, and to divide the ownership of these enterprises between the Ministries of Economy and Finance, which the Ministry of Economy does not agree with.

In a separate commentary to Business Media, the Minister of Economy and Sustainable development, and Vice Prime Minister of Georgia, Levan Davitashvili stated that the revival of the Stand-by Arrangement /SBA doesn’t depend on the reform of SOE law. He noted that the IMF suggested changes have already been tested in a pilot regime.

“As a result, many nuances have been identified that should be reflected in the final legislation, including how state-owned enterprises should be managed and, of course, and their ownership. This is a very complex issue because these are important corporations that are the backbone of our country’s economy. Therefore, we have had a very open dialogue with our partners, the World Bank has been actively involved in this process, this dialogue is continuing, because the model should be clear, well- organized and serve the economic interests of Georgia. This is what we are talking about with the IMF, they understand it. This cannot be done quickly, in one day,” – stated Levan Davitashvili.

Also Read:


Categories
South Caucasus News

IMF Calls for Bolstering Judicial System, Anti-corruption Authority in Staff Concluding Statement


On March 18, the International Monetary Fund (IMF) released the preliminary findings of the IMF staff during its official visit to Georgia on March 6-18. The concluding statement, to the publication of which the authorities have consented, provides an overview of the economic situation in Georgia and suggests that the country should strengthen its resilience to adverse shocks by maintaining prudent macroeconomic policies, and raise its growth potential by addressing long-standing structural challenges.

A Concluding Statement describes the preliminary findings of IMF staff at the end of an official staff visit (or ‘mission’), in most cases to a member country. Missions are undertaken as part of regular (usually annual) consultations under Article IV of the IMF’s Articles of Agreement, in the context of a request to use IMF resources (borrow from the IMF), as part of discussions of staff monitored programs, or as part of other staff monitoring of economic developments.

Recent developments, outlook, and risks

The IMF notes that despite the economic crises following Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, Georgia’s financial inflows remain above pre-war levels, supporting “continued strong economic performance.” GDP stood at 7.5% in 2023 and is expected by IMF staff to decline to 5.7% in 2024, “with consumption playing a larger role supported by strong real wage growth and employment.”

Regarding inflation, the IMF states that the 0.4% reached in 2023 is expected to rise to 4% by the end of this year “as the impact of last year’s favorable external factors dissipates and the restrictive monetary policy stance is unwound”. The current account deficit is also expected to widen, from a historically low 4.5% of GDP in 2023 (mainly due to lower remittances from Russia) to 6% by the end of 2024.

The IMF notes that the 2024 budget targets a deficit of 2.5%, supported by higher revenues from corporate income tax (CIT) and new gambling taxes. This will finance higher spending on wages, social benefits and capital investment, while keeping public debt below 40% of GDP.

However, the expected downside risks include uncertainty about war-related migrants and financial inflows, potential reversals in migration and tourism, and geopolitical instability. A loss of momentum or backsliding in the reform agenda is also named as a downside risk. Upside risks include increased transit trade and investments, with shifting geo-economic patterns creating new trade opportunities, and EU candidate status sending a positive signal to investors, says the concluding statement.

Policy priorities

“Macroeconomic and financial policies should be geared towards ensuring strong, sustained, and inclusive growth, continued resilience in the face of an uncertain external environment, and the goal of making decisive progress towards EU accession,” suggests the statement.

Regarding fiscal policy, the IMF staff recommends “modest fiscal adjustments” supported by a focus on revenue enhancement, streamlined tax policies, and efficient spending. In addition, the implementation of reforms in state-owned enterprises (SOEs) and the development of renewable energy is crucial to boost productivity, limit fiscal risks, and align with EU principles.

The IMF emphasizes that the SOE law should ensure that the Ministry of Finance is adequately empowered to play a strong oversight role to monitor and mitigate fiscal risks, as well as limit the state’s interests in line with the Stand-By Arrangement signed in 2022. “Efforts to concretely reduce the state’s footprint in the economy need to be intensified.” The statement also says the authorities should proceed with the opening of the electricity market, which has been delayed again.

Regarding monetary and exchange rate policies, the IMF notes that continued exchange rate flexibility and reserve accumulation are necessary to guard against adverse external shocks, and that strengthening the governance and independence of the NBG is essential for the credibility of monetary policy. “In this regard, the NBG law should be amended to i) ensure a non-executive majority on the NBG’s oversight board, ii) clarify and strengthen the succession framework and board member qualification criteria, and iii) move from a presidential to collegial decision-making model.”

Financial sector resilience and structural reforms

The concluding statement highlights that the Georgian banking system is “well capitalized, profitable, and liquid but remains highly concentrated and dollarized.” It also underlines that “continued vigilance is needed against financial sector risks, including from capital inflows, virtual assets, and sanctions.”

The IMF notes that to foster robust growth, Georgia must improve education, productivity, infrastructure, and governance. This includes enhancing teaching quality, agricultural productivity, and land management, while also investing in transport, logistics, and energy.

“While Georgia ranks high in the region and among EU candidates regarding the rule of law and absence of corruption, recent years have seen some slippages in governance indicators. To ensure that governance standards strengthen and support improved competitiveness, Georgia needs to bolster its judicial system and strengthen the anti-corruption authority,” – notes the statement.

Also Read:


Categories
South Caucasus News

Government Increases Funding For Patriarchate


On March 19, the Prime Minister of Georgia Irakli Kobakhidze said that last year the government earmarked GEL 30 million [est. USD 11,194,000] in the 2024 state budget to support the educational projects of the Patriarchate of Georgia, which was since increased by GEL 5 million [about USD 1,866,000]. The decree, setting the amount at GEL 35 million was issued by the government on March 15.

In addition to these funds, the Patriarchate of Georgia also receives the annual funding in the amount of GEL 25 million [est. USD 9,328,000], bringing the total amount of state funding to GEL 60 million [est. USD 22,388,000] in 2024.

Prime Minister Irakli Kobakhidze denied that the increase has anything to do with the upcoming elections: “This funding was included in this year’s budget last year, so it has nothing to do with the elections, it is not a recent decision, a decision made right before the elections. It is important for us that the Patriarchate can implement its own projects, especially in the field of education.”

Meanwhile, on March 12, the Georgian government issued a decree handing over plots of land to the Orthodox Church in the Ozurgeti and Chokhatauri municipalities in western Georgia for a symbolic price of GEL 1 [USD 0.37].


Categories
South Caucasus News

Secrets Of The Lake: At A Georgian Church Camp, A Cleric Is Accused Of Being A Predator


Five women in Georgia have alleged that they were sexually abused by a metropolitan in the Georgian Orthodox Church, raising troubling questions about the impunity enjoyed by high-ranking clerics.

Categories
South Caucasus News

@yeghig: Hassan Beheshtipour: #Russia Knows #Iran Will Cross the Aras River #SouthCaucasus #Armenia #Azerbaijan https://t.co/H1u6a46493


Hassan Beheshtipour: #Russia Knows #Iran Will Cross the Aras River#SouthCaucasus #Armenia #Azerbaijan https://t.co/H1u6a46493

— Yeghia Tashjian #FreeArmenianPOWs 🇱🇧🇦🇲 (@yeghig) March 19, 2024


Categories
Audio Review - South Caucasus News

Armenia’s prime minister says quick border demarcation needed to avoid new conflict with Azerbaijan


UUNLW6XF5AI65HV2CVMPQSHMEU_size-normaliz

YEREVAN, Armenia — Armenia’s prime minister said Tuesday that the Caucasus nation needs to quickly define the border with neighboring Azerbaijan to avoid a new round of hostilities.

Last year, Azerbaijan waged a lightning military campaign to reclaim the Karabakh region, ending three decades of ethnic Armenian separatists’ rule there.

In December, the two sides agreed to begin negotiations on a peace treaty. However, many residents of Armenia’s border regions have resisted the demarcation effort, seeing it as Azerbaijan’s encroachment on the areas they consider their own.

Speaking to residents of the border village of Voskepar in the Tavush region, Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan warned that Armenia’s refusal to delineate the border could trigger a new confrontation.

“It would mean that a war could erupt by the end of the week,” Pashinyan said. He noted that the border demarcation should be based on mutual recognition of territorial integrity of Armenia and Azerbaijan based on Soviet maps from 1991, when they were both were part of the Soviet Union.

“We shouldn’t allow the war to start,” Pashinyan said. “And this is also the reason that we decided to go to delimitation of the borders in these parts of Armenia.”

The opposition has blamed Pashinyan and has organized a long series of protests against him for allowing Azerbaijan to rout ethnic Armenian forces and reclaim control over Karabakh. The region, known internationally as Nagorno-Karabakh, and large swaths of surrounding territory came under full control of ethnic Armenian forces backed by Armenia at the end of a separatist war in 1994.

Azerbaijan regained parts of Karabakh and most of the surrounding territory in a six-week war in 2020. It then launched a blitz last September that routed the separatist forces in one day and forced them to lay down arms. More than 100,000 ethnic Armenians fled the region after that, leaving it nearly deserted.

The hostilities have badly strained Russia-Armenia ties, with Armenian authorities accusing Russian peacekeepers who were deployed to Nagorno-Karabakh after the 2020 war of failing to stop September’s onslaught by Azerbaijan. Moscow, which has a military base in Armenia, has rejected the accusations, arguing that its troops didn’t have a mandate to intervene.

Moscow, in turn, has been angered by Pashinyan’s efforts to deepen ties with the West and distance his country from a Russia-dominated security alliance of ex-Soviet nations. Russia was also vexed by Armenia’s decision to join the International Criminal Court, which last year indicted Russian President Vladimir Putin for alleged war crimes connected with the war in Ukraine.

Pashinyan underlined Armenia’s intention to forge close relations with the West when he hosted visiting NATO Secretary-General Jens Stoltenberg for talks on Tuesday.

“We want to continue and develop the existing political dialogue and expand our partnership with the alliance and some of its members,” Pashinyan said after the talks.

He said Yerevan would welcome NATO’s efforts to help normalize ties between Armenia and Azerbaijan.

“We expect strong support from the international community, including NATO, for the peace process between Armenia and Azerbaijan,” he said.

Stoltenberg, who traveled to Armenia to wrap up his three-day tour of the South Caucasus region that also involved visits to Azerbaijan and Georgia, praised Armenia for its contribution to NATO peacekeeping operations, including the alliance’s peacekeeping mission in Kosovo. “NATO supports Armenian sovereignty and territorial integrity, and your peaceful aspirations,” he said.

Stoltenberg emphasized the need for for Armenia and Azerbaijan to reach an agreement on normalizing ties, emphasizing that “this matters for Euro-Atlantic security as we face a more dangerous world.”

During his visit to Azerbaijan on Sunday, the NATO chief encouraged it to “seize this opportunity to reach a lasting peace agreement with Armenia.”


Categories
Selected Articles

Armenia’s prime minister says quick border demarcation needed to avoid new conflict with Azerbaijan


UUNLW6XF5AI65HV2CVMPQSHMEU_size-normaliz

YEREVAN, Armenia — Armenia’s prime minister said Tuesday that the Caucasus nation needs to quickly define the border with neighboring Azerbaijan to avoid a new round of hostilities.

Last year, Azerbaijan waged a lightning military campaign to reclaim the Karabakh region, ending three decades of ethnic Armenian separatists’ rule there.

In December, the two sides agreed to begin negotiations on a peace treaty. However, many residents of Armenia’s border regions have resisted the demarcation effort, seeing it as Azerbaijan’s encroachment on the areas they consider their own.

Speaking to residents of the border village of Voskepar in the Tavush region, Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan warned that Armenia’s refusal to delineate the border could trigger a new confrontation.

“It would mean that a war could erupt by the end of the week,” Pashinyan said. He noted that the border demarcation should be based on mutual recognition of territorial integrity of Armenia and Azerbaijan based on Soviet maps from 1991, when they were both were part of the Soviet Union.

“We shouldn’t allow the war to start,” Pashinyan said. “And this is also the reason that we decided to go to delimitation of the borders in these parts of Armenia.”

The opposition has blamed Pashinyan and has organized a long series of protests against him for allowing Azerbaijan to rout ethnic Armenian forces and reclaim control over Karabakh. The region, known internationally as Nagorno-Karabakh, and large swaths of surrounding territory came under full control of ethnic Armenian forces backed by Armenia at the end of a separatist war in 1994.

Azerbaijan regained parts of Karabakh and most of the surrounding territory in a six-week war in 2020. It then launched a blitz last September that routed the separatist forces in one day and forced them to lay down arms. More than 100,000 ethnic Armenians fled the region after that, leaving it nearly deserted.

The hostilities have badly strained Russia-Armenia ties, with Armenian authorities accusing Russian peacekeepers who were deployed to Nagorno-Karabakh after the 2020 war of failing to stop September’s onslaught by Azerbaijan. Moscow, which has a military base in Armenia, has rejected the accusations, arguing that its troops didn’t have a mandate to intervene.

Moscow, in turn, has been angered by Pashinyan’s efforts to deepen ties with the West and distance his country from a Russia-dominated security alliance of ex-Soviet nations. Russia was also vexed by Armenia’s decision to join the International Criminal Court, which last year indicted Russian President Vladimir Putin for alleged war crimes connected with the war in Ukraine.

Pashinyan underlined Armenia’s intention to forge close relations with the West when he hosted visiting NATO Secretary-General Jens Stoltenberg for talks on Tuesday.

“We want to continue and develop the existing political dialogue and expand our partnership with the alliance and some of its members,” Pashinyan said after the talks.

He said Yerevan would welcome NATO’s efforts to help normalize ties between Armenia and Azerbaijan.

“We expect strong support from the international community, including NATO, for the peace process between Armenia and Azerbaijan,” he said.

Stoltenberg, who traveled to Armenia to wrap up his three-day tour of the South Caucasus region that also involved visits to Azerbaijan and Georgia, praised Armenia for its contribution to NATO peacekeeping operations, including the alliance’s peacekeeping mission in Kosovo. “NATO supports Armenian sovereignty and territorial integrity, and your peaceful aspirations,” he said.

Stoltenberg emphasized the need for for Armenia and Azerbaijan to reach an agreement on normalizing ties, emphasizing that “this matters for Euro-Atlantic security as we face a more dangerous world.”

During his visit to Azerbaijan on Sunday, the NATO chief encouraged it to “seize this opportunity to reach a lasting peace agreement with Armenia.”


Categories
South Caucasus News

Democratic Transformation and Obstruction: EU, US, and Russia in the South Caucasus – Foreign Policy Research Institute


Democratic Transformation and Obstruction: EU, US, and Russia in the South Caucasus  Foreign Policy Research Institute