February 1, 2024 - The South Caucasus News - SouthCaucasusNews.com

Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan on Thursday said that peace would be impossible as long as Armenia’s Declaration of Independence calls for the unification of Armenia and Artsakh. The prime minister’s comments come on the heels of President Ilham Aliyev demanding changes to Armenia’s Constitution.

«We will never have peace if the Declaration of Independence contains a decision to unify Artsakh and the Republic of Armenia,” Pashinyan told the Armenian Public Radio during an interview on Thursday.

Armenia’s independence declaration was adopted in 1990 and contained the imperative to unify Armenia and Artsakh. That sentiment is also echoed in Armenia’s Constitution.

On the anniversary of the Declaration of Independence in August, Pashianyan criticized the document, saying it sows enmity and war.

During the interview, he also reiterated the need to adopt a new constitution while acknowledging that a reform process is currently underway, with a special commission tasked to represent amendment to the Constitution.

He said that a new constitution will go a long way to address what he called a “gap between the citizens and the state.”

Pashinyan said that such a gap existed because the Armenian Constitution, which was adopted in 1995 — and modified thereafter — “was never adopted under conditions and an environment where the citizen of the Republic of Armenia could say: ‘I went, voted, and adopted the Constitution.’ In other words: ‘I went and recorded my agreement with other citizens and the state, that we relate to each other this way and live this way.’”

He claimed that a constitutional referendum will allow citizens Armenia to exercise their “own free will, without coercion, without falsification, without manipulation, and established the agreement.”

Pashinyan emphasized the importance of the Constitution having an organic connection with the people.

“The organic connection with the people is not only expressed by the fact that we have to discuss, understand all the nuances, and remove all the formulations. The text of the constitution is mostly a matter for professional discussion and wording to serve the political guidelines, but the organic link with the state — the organic link with the people — is formed from the moment when the people accept and confirm this condition, and record that they are ‘a state people’ and record that within the borders of this state, we will relate to each other according to these rules,” said Pashinyan.

Pashinyan also emphasized that the government cannot change the Constitution.

“The government can propose to the people, engage in discussions with the people, present its explanations to the people, and only the people can make that decision,” said Pashinyan.

Karen Aghajanyan

In the Armenia Tree Project (ATP) office in Yerevan, which is filled with the comforting aroma of tea, we sit down with Karen Aghajanyan, a displaced Artsakh resident and now an ATP employee, to discuss his journey. Aghajanyan, among the 120,000 displaced, comes from Askeran. He now dedicates his skills to ATP’s Backyard Nursery Program.

His profound connection to the land, which was cultivated through generations, faced a tumultuous turn when conflict swept through Artsakh, encircling it in a blockade. Our conversation explores the trials of life amid the blockade, subsequent war and exodus, and the resilience needed to rebuild after bidding farewell to one’s homeland. Drawing on his extensive background, including overseeing agriculture in Askeran and serving as the former Deputy Minister of Agriculture, Aghajanyan shares experiences and insights, notably his role in ATP’s impactful Backyard Greenhouse Project in his native region.

ATP: Can you describe your personal experiences during the blockade, particularly how you navigated the challenges and what impact it had on your life?

Karen Aghajanyan (K.A.): I was in Yerevan when the blockade started. I had come for a medical appointment on December 11, 2022, intending to return the next day. However, the roads closed, and I was stranded in Goris for 27 days. I joined a group of fellow Artsakhtsis, navigating a military-designed route through forests and rocky mountains to get back home. Despite the difficulty, the urgency to get to my family drove me forward, and thankfully, we were reunited.

Initially, we believed the blockade would be short-lived, but it persisted until the very end. Food shortages were severe. Villagers with stored provisions managed to endure, but city dwellers faced more dire circumstances. Urban living became increasingly challenging due to a shortage of fuel. The limited supply was used sparingly, mainly for essential agricultural tasks like harvesting.

The scarcity of bread became critical as our enemies actively prevented the harvesting of wheat fields, resorting to gunfire against field workers. Before the 2020 war, Artsakh produced over 100,000 tons of wheat, significantly impacting Armenia’s economy. The loss of Artsakh is not just an economic setback; it’s a huge blow to our security as well, with Azeris now not only at the border but also encroaching on Armenian territory.

For over a month, trucks carrying humanitarian aid from Armenia were stranded at the border, denied entry. On September 18, two Red Cross trucks from Azerbaijan were finally allowed into Stepanakert; however, war erupted the next day, prompting our evacuation. The Azeri forces approached populated areas, with Martuni and Martakert experiencing atrocities as their roads to Stepanakert were sealed. They entered villages, taking hostages, causing fatalities. They had completely encircled Artsakh, and while we resisted and inflicted damage, fighting to the end would have resulted in everyone’s demise, especially with no assistance from Armenia or any other country – no help was expected or received.

Did you ever foresee a situation where everyone would be compelled to leave?

If Artsakh wasn’t surrounded and if there had been an open corridor to Armenia, nobody would have left. The encirclement left us with no choice – either integrate or leave. Not even in our worst nightmares did we imagine the entire population leaving, but the circumstances forced us.

Of course, integration was out of the question due to the recent conflicts and atrocities. The vast difference in civility and society levels makes reconciliation impossible with Azeris. The brutal methods they employ, such as beheadings, mirror historical aggression against us. They undergo constant indoctrination and are taught from a young age that Armenians are enemies. Their leaders perpetuate distorted historical narratives, denying Armenians’ ancient heritage, which hinders any possibility of reconciliation.

The war and tragic gas depot explosion created an incredibly challenging situation. Many, like myself, have experienced every war since the 90s and have no desire for more. Witnessing the losses and tragedies, including fathers, sons and children in the same family, has made people reluctant to endure further conflict and to subject their descendants to such situations. The toll is too great.

Can you describe your displacement and arrival in Armenia?

We departed for Armenia on September 25, just a day after the road opened. It took us 30 hours to get here by car, with limited belongings – mainly clothing and some food. Our main concern was the future, pondering where we would live and how we would sustain ourselves. We faced no major issues on the road, although others weren’t as fortunate, encountering theft and interrogations by Azeri military. After a day in Goris and about 10 days in Abovyan, we settled in Yerevan, where we currently reside.

What was the hardest part?

Abandoning our ancestral home, large enough for 20-30 people. In hindsight it becomes even more difficult, as we realize that we left behind the culmination of generations’ efforts, including the resting places of our forebears.

My grandmother used to share stories of escaping the Turkish attacks in 1918-1920, when they sought refuge in the next village. A similar pattern unfolded in the 90s. However, in the recent conflict, the Azeri military’s advanced weaponry eliminated any possibility of escape or hiding within villages. It’s painful that, for the first time in history, there’s no Armenians left in Artsakh, and with no way back.

What key factors are essential for displaced families to be able to rebuild a sustainable life here?

Many, like myself, wish to remain in Armenia. The primary challenge for displaced families is securing stable work and housing. Without government support, ongoing rent expenses make sustainability difficult. While there’s talk of programs or neighborhoods for Artsakhtsis, nothing concrete has materialized. If displaced Artsakhtsi families in Armenia can secure stable housing, it would significantly deter migration. Providing a home is often enough to encourage families to stay.

What led you to work with the Armenia Tree Project?

In early September 2021, I met with Jeanmarie (ATP Executive Director) to discuss the proposed Backyard Greenhouse Project in Artsakh. I had helped them build and manage the project. I met again with Jeanmarie in October 2023 to discuss the fate of the project and of Artsakh. During the meeting, they offered me a job with the NGO, and without much hesitation, I accepted. I was already familiar with the organization and its mission. Currently, I’m working on the Backyard Nursery Program, which aligns well with my profession. I appreciate the opportunity to visit provinces daily and meet people, many of whom have been refugees, so we share a unique understanding of each other’s experiences. Helping them becomes a way for me to find some peace and purpose.

Can you provide insights into your background and what life was like in Artsakh before?

I spent all my 60 years in Askeran, where I was born and raised. It had been home not just to me but also my parents and grandparents. We were four siblings – two sisters, two brothers. I remained in my father’s house. I graduated from the Armenian National Agrarian University in Yerevan and chose to return to Askeran immediately after, despite tempting offers to stay. Living in Artsakh offered favorable conditions for both life and work. The nature was incredibly abundant, with almost no winter in Askeran. After a few days of snow, warmth would return, making life there easy and enjoyable.

I was responsible for curating agriculture in Askeran District. Prior to that I worked in the Ministry of Agriculture as the Deputy Minister. I helped manage agricultural programs throughout Artsakh. The region’s milder climate allowed for diverse agricultural pursuits, although vegetable production traditionally lagged. Historically, Artsakhtsis mostly dealt with animal farming and viticulture, which was very much developed. There was huge potential and lots of progress being made.

In recent years, I collaborated with organizations like Armenia Tree Project and Green Lane NGO to establish 24 backyard greenhouses in Askeran, providing families with valuable training to cultivate vegetables. It was a crucial contributor to food security and self-sustainability within the community. I think it was in August of 2021 when ATP first came to us with the project. Our reaction was very positive, and in just a few months we started construction. It was a great experience for the families to start small. They were motivated and getting new ideas for adding crops and expanding, but of course, everything was disrupted. During the blockade, we received potato seeds, and the greenhouses emerged as a beacon of sustenance, providing nourishment to many when food was scarce.

Did you personally engage in cultivation, aside from your involvement in the greenhouse project?

I used my free time after work to grow a variety of crops, supplying my family and relatives. We had excellent apples all year round, particularly the delightful Pink Lady, a delicious variety that I brought from the U.S. I grew pears, persimmons, as well as staple crops like wheat, corn.

Could you share more details about your family and current living arrangements?

I have two sons; one of them is married and has my only grandchild, Karen Jr. They currently live with me as my son and his wife continue their job search. My grandson tells me, “Let’s go back to Askeran. I don’t like it here.” Unfortunately, there’s no space at the kindergartens and long waiting lists. Currently, we reside in a rented apartment in Komitas, Yerevan. Without our own home, the future is uncertain, and I can’t predict how long we’ll stay in our current situation or what lies ahead for us.

When you contemplate the future, what are your thoughts and aspirations?

My hope centers around my children, the youth. Having lived most of my life already, my primary concern is for them and their future, hoping they can stand on their own two feet.

As a concluding question, we always like to ask: Which tree holds a special place in your heart?

I’m especially fond of the platanus tree. It brings back memories of home in Askeran, where 60-70-year-old plane trees dotted the landscape and were visible from every corner. The longevity of the plane tree resonates with me, and in our region, we call it Tnjri.

Author information

Armenia Tree Project

Armenia Tree Project (ATP) is a non-profit program based in Woburn and Yerevan conducting vitally important environmental projects in Armenia’s cities and villages and seeks support in advancing its reforestation mission. Since 1994, ATP has planted and restored more than 6,000,000 trees, and hundreds of jobs have been created for Armenians in seasonal tree-related programs.

The post Rooted in resilience: A conversation with ATP’s Karen Aghajanyan of Artsakh appeared first on The Armenian Weekly.